I define a strength as an activity that strengthens you and a weakness as an activity that weakens you.
— Marcus Buckingham
I’ve stopped writing many times in the past because I psyched myself out. I rarely read creative nonfiction. What business do I have writing it?
I read fiction. When it comes time for pleasure reading, novels have my heart. So why would I produce what I do not consume? It makes no sense for me to continue if I don’t even write the type of work I choose to read.
I’m reading The Forest for the Trees: An Editor’s Advice to Writers by Betsy Lerner, and in the first chapter, she talks about finding your form as a writer. Do you write nonfiction? Poetry? Novels? Because whatever you write — whatever you gravitate to — is your form. Despite trends, despite what’s selling now, despite what you consume in your leisure time, write the form that works for you. (The fact that I am reading a nonfiction book is not lost on me. Well, it kind of was until I just re-read this. I guess I do read nonfiction, just not at night, in bed, in my leisure reading time).
And it occurred to me, a professional chef does not only eat the type of cuisine she specializes in; an Olympic swimmer does not only attend swim meets when he consumes sports in his leisure time. A pastry chef doesn’t stop baking because she loves savory soups, nor does a swimmer stop swimming because he loves to watch tennis.
As I digested this new way of thinking, that it’s okay for me to keep writing even if my preferred leisure reading is different from what I personally produce, I thought about the way writing makes me feel (productive, fulfilled), and I remembered a podcast I listened to a few months ago. It was an EntreLeadership interview with Marcus Buckingham, a former senior researcher with Gallup who has studied strengths for more than 30 years, where he surprised me with his definition of a strength as something that strengthens you, not just as something you have an innate talent for, or are good at.
Other people might say that a strength is what you’re good at and a weakness is what you’re bad at, but I don’t find that a very compelling definition because frankly there are many things that I am quite good at that bore me or drain me or for which I have zero passion, but I’m good at them.
He describes how some people build entire careers on the mistaken notion that a strength is something you’re good at, like medical professionals who became doctors because they were good at biochemistry. When they got into the job realized they don’t like sick people, but sadly, every day, there are more sick people lined up at their door.
This definition of strengths resonates with me because I find truth in it. I excelled in math and science in school. I started to build a career in science, even got my degree in a biological field, but ultimately realized the work itself did not interest me. The day-to-day activity of life in a lab did not energize me. I had no passion for it. Science was not my strength, despite an aptitude for it in school.
Yet, I continued to read and write, and gain energy from them.
Writing this blog, writing in my journal, writing for work, it all invigorates me. Communicating via words on a screen or a page is the activity I gravitate to, it is how I choose to spend my time when I manage to carve out free time, it is where I find flow, where time disappears, where I produce things I’m proud of. Writing is what I reward myself with at home — “When I get the grocery list done, I can write ten pages/brain dump my morning/edit my blog post” — and at work — “When I finish these tasks, I can write that P2 post/review that draft/revise that page.”
In other words, writing strengthens me. It sustains me despite the lack of results: I’ve not received a single paycheck for my writing, no awards, no print publications. I’ve barely submitted work anywhere, but I have more than 40 filled journals going back as far as 1982 (when I was 8), five blogs with more than 700 entries, and more than 1,200 internal blog posts at work (438,000+ words). The lack of adornments, as Buckingham calls the rewards people seek when they want the fame or the money or status of a role but don’t actually love the activity of the work, have not stopped the words from coming out.
I write because I love to write, and creative nonfiction is the form that fits me best. Reading fiction exposes me to stories, paragraphs, sentences, and words the same as any other reading would do. It exposes me to structure, to vocabulary, to themes. It makes me feel, it makes me think. It is different from what I write, so it exposes me to different points of view. Reading fiction should not stop me from writing nonfiction.
Nothing should stop me from writing, in fact, except simple desire. Our strengths — the activities we do that strengthen us — are what energize us and help us thrive. It makes no sense to stop doing them.
You provided wonderful reasons for your choice of writing and why your strength does not have to be your “go to.” I write because I must. Without it, breathing, cooking, exercising, relating in the world is gray. Yogis say be the witness to your life, the filter through which experiences flow. Words flow through that screen.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thank you for this!
LikeLike
I’m glad you found your justification for writing because your words enrich not just you but your readers as well. Great post!
LikeLike
This is so true. It’s how I have felt about career paths, school and writing. I think my dad was the one that pointed out that I was getting stronger in math because I was spending so much time with it. Where I once thought I was weak, I got stronger. Thanks for your post. Blessings to you.
LikeLike
Thank you for this! I pursue many creative endeavours because they strengthen me, but am often caught questioning whether its worth it or not because they aren’t leading to a paycheque/success/ etc.. This is just the perspective shift that I needed 🙂
LikeLike
Peter Meinke is the current Poet Laureate for Florida. He’s written an excellent book called “The Shape of Poetry: A Practical Guide to Writing/Reading Poems.”
What he says about writing poetry, and writing in general, makes a lot of sense to me. Here are a few of his words of advice:
“Writing poetry — like all writing for publication — is a tough game. It puts you on the line to be judged over and over, by yourself as well as others.
“…take an attitude toward your own work that I will call a kind of ‘stubborn modesty.’
All of us need to be open to suggestions, advice, criticism, to be modest about our work…
“At the same time, you have to be stubborn. If, after you’ve listened and considered and read and studied, you remain unconvinced, you’ve got to stick to your own guns, against editors, reviewers, the public…
“Writers are naturally subversive: They’re born rule-breakers. As soon as a rule is stated — that poems have to be unified, or have related images, or be written in stanzas — somebody will successfully break the rule. But you have to know what you’re doing, and why.
“Writing is worth doing, whether you publish it or not. I think Emily Dickinson was happiest when she was writing, her poems piling up like old love letters in her closet…If you’re hooked on the physical act of writing, you have a good chance of staying at it long enough to say what you were born to say. And if someone recognizes and rewards this, that’s a bonus.”
LikeLike
Again, I totally feel you! I have to admit though, I am- or was- one of the people who believed that our strengths are innate within us. It’s what we’re naturally good at. But reading your post and Buckingham’s reasoning, I realize I’ve been wrong this entire time. It’s a new perspective to adjust to, but it makes perfect sense. A strength is something that betters us. Got it.
Thanks for this insightful post!
LikeLike
I listened to this same episode and made the same notes for myself! ❤
LikeLiked by 1 person
Very interesting. Like you, I read fiction all the time. I hardly pick up non-fiction books. But maybe because I lack ideas to write fiction myself, and yet I like writing, stringing words together to tell a story, I write nonfiction. I write about stuff that has happened around me, my opinions on them. I guess that makes me a creative nonfiction writer?
LikeLike