I struggle with gift-giving. Giving physical objects can be hit or miss. What if you give someone something they don’t want, and they feel like they’ll hurt your feelings if they don’t like whatever you gave them, and you’ve wasted money, and they feel obligated to keep it, and it takes up space in their home or shelf or drawer, and it makes them feel crappy every time they look at it? That’s the opposite of what I want to happen when I give someone a gift. I want to give something that lights them up! That brings them joy!
Having a list to work from helps a lot with this. I’d much rather give something I know someone wants, even if that takes away the element of surprise. I used to think this was cheating, and feels less thoughtful, and less creative. But I listened to a great Hidden Brain podcast episode, I think it was The Secret to Gift Giving, that basically says, look, when you try to get creative with gifts and aren’t very good at it, it becomes about you as the gift giver — you’re trying to get the Wow! factor — rather than about the person you’re giving the gift to. In those cases, working from a wishlist and giving something the person actually wants is the thoughtful thing to do. They want something, you give it to them, they feel joy. I felt joy when I opened the backpack I really wanted, our daughter felt joy when she opened the perfume she wanted.
But what’s most fun is to give an experience. That’s become my favorite type of gift to give and receive. We took our kids to an NHL hockey game this year, and they loved that. We have fun memories now from that time together. My parents sent a charcuterie board for my birthday that my husband and I enjoyed one night with wine on the back deck. I remember how great it felt to not have to make a meal. I took my husband to New York City jazz clubs for his 50th birthday, and we had a fantastic time while we were there, and now have fantastic memories as well.
Apparently, this is one of the secrets to happiness, according to all of the happiness research I’ve been listening to the past couple of years: to share time together, and to connect socially. For maximal happiness, the best gift to give is the gift of experiences.
Our seven year old daughter gave me a gift this Christmas that continues to impress me, not because of the gift itself, but because of her reason for giving it.
I am a baker. I have loved to bake since I first stood on a wooden gray stool next to my mom and felt chocolate chip cookie dough stiffen as I stirred flour into it. As I matured as a baker, I became interested in learning more about the science behind baking, about ingredients, and about how to make baked goods even better. I’ve collected bread and pastry books over the years, and have deepened my understanding of yeast doughs, but more recently, I have expressed often, and to whomever will listen, that I’d really like to understand cakes and desserts better. Hint hint.
So I was thrilled when I ripped the shiny red paper off of our daughter’s gift to me. She sat at my knee with her hands clasped, and her eyes glittered above her “I hope you like it!” grin. The gift was Maida Heatter’s Book of Great Chocolate Desserts. I oohed and aahed and hugged our daughter, laughing with her infectious excitement, as her dad explained that they had done tons of research trying to find a good baking book, and that apparently this Maida Heatter was THE woman for baked desserts. None of us had ever heard of her, but I was touched by the amount of thought that had gone into this gift.
I thumbed through the recipes and our daughter climbed into the chair with me. “Thank you, sweetie,” I said, and kissed the top of her head.
“You’re welcome, Mommy.” She put her arms around me and said, “I got you this because I really want to bake with you.”
I stopped thumbing and looked at her sweet, earnest face. I thought of all the times she asked to help in the kitchen, and all the times I was too rushed, or too uptight about measuring the flour myself. I thought about her putting on her apron just to tear open packets for her Easy Bake Oven, and the glee she felt every time I asked her to measure the sugar or crack an egg for real baking.
“I would love that, baby.” And I meant it. Though she didn’t realize it, her desire to bake with me, after all my crabbiness and stinginess in the kitchen, was her true gift. She was giving me an opportunity to slow down and teach her the art of baking. An opportunity to learn it myself. An opportunity to spend time with my daughter, doing something we both love.
Since that day, we have made an orange chocolate loaf cake, two kinds of brownies, a chocolate pumpkin cake, and our most recent creation, a chocolate-marbleized cheesecake. All from this mysterious woman’s cookbook. Because of the depth of our daughter’s gift, I make sure to make an event of baking these creations together. I say yes when she asks, “Can I measure the vanilla? Can I do the mixer? Can I separate the eggs?”
She now adds fractions in her head, knows you can make 3/4 of a cup by either using a half cup plus a quarter cup or three quarter cup measures, and can tell you why you use a double boiler to melt chocolate. She knows she must be exact with flour, baking soda, and baking powder, but that vanilla is just for flavor, not for chemistry, and so it’s okay if you dump a little more. She uses caution when reaching over burners to turn on the oven, knows to turn pot handles so they don’t hang over the edge, loves to melt chocolate.
And if someone asks her what she wants to be when she grows up? She says, “An artist or,” be still my heart, “A pastry chef.”
As for me, I am learning, too. About baking, yes, but even more than that. With this gift, our daughter has taught me to teach her. To allow. To say yes. She has opened me to taking risks. To letting her measure the flour, the salt, the vanilla. To letting her get close enough to feel the heat of the stove and the oven. To let her spill, and wipe up her mess.
For our seven year old daughter, I am learning to let go, a little bit, of control.
From our seven year old daughter, I am learning how to trust.
When my foodie friend was over, she did a double take when she saw the new addition to our cookbooks. “Oh my God! Maida Heatter!” She grabbed the manual and studied the cover. “My old boss at Delightful Bitefuls – remember? the catering company in Athens? – she used to always talk about ‘Maeeda Heeta’ this and ‘Maeeda Heeta’ that.” My friend flipped the book over and read the reviews. “So that’s how you spell her name. I could never figure it out to find her cookbooks. And here she is.”
We weren’t even in our new place before packages started showing up on our doorstep. Since we were geniuses and crammed our move into the two weeks between our kids’ birthdays (and only four weeks before Christmas), we did a lot of online ordering to make sure we didn’t screw up and forget to shop for our kids amidst all the moving-in hubbub.
As a result, our mail carrier and UPS man have been frequent visitors to our front stoop. I introduced myself to our new mail carrier – she comes during daylight hours, and her arrival was easy to anticipate. But our UPS guy? The other night, our doorbell rang, and we answered it within 10 seconds. Seriously, it was that quick. There lay a package at our door, with not a man nor a brown truck to be seen. I swear to God, there was no UPS truck or deliveryman anywhere in sight, no tail lights disappearing down the street, no diesel engine gurgling away into the night. It was kind of creepy.
When it came time to leave our holiday tips, the mail carrier was easy. I wrote her a card, slipped some cash in it, and left it with the outgoing mail. But the UPS man? I don’t even know what he looks like. Or when to expect him. Or if I can catch him the next time he comes to our door.
So yesterday, when I saw the brown UPS truck pull into our parking lot, I stole the card I had set aside for the kids’ librarian, scribbled a thank you note, and ran out in my slippers waving the red envelope, “Excuse me! Excuse me!” chasing him as he sprinted from our neighbors’ stoop to his open-doored truck.
“I wasn’t sure if we’d be getting any more packages delivered before Christmas, but I wanted to give you a card. So here you go. Merry Christmas!” Panting as I said it.
He stopped mid trot, looked at me real funny, like “Who the hell are you?” and then his face gentled and he said thank you as he accepted my card.
I realized after his funny look that a) he was here way earlier than we usually get our deliveries, so I don’t even know if he’s our UPS man, and b) since he hopped into the passenger side of the truck, I’m guessing there was a driver with him, whom I did not tip. Sigh. I’ll get it right one of these days.
If you are bewildered by the art of tipping like I am, my husband sent me this excellent guide to tipping. It even includes the percentage rates for hair cuts – I never know how much to tip my stylist! Now to figure out how to catch the garbage men. I don’t know when they come or how many serve our building. But after the sickening volume of waste we generated from our move, you’d better believe I appreciate those guys enough to sit by the window all day Friday to wait for them.