I struggle with gift-giving. Giving physical objects can be hit or miss. What if you give someone something they don’t want, and they feel like they’ll hurt your feelings if they don’t like whatever you gave them, and you’ve wasted money, and they feel obligated to keep it, and it takes up space in their home or shelf or drawer, and it makes them feel crappy every time they look at it? That’s the opposite of what I want to happen when I give someone a gift. I want to give something that lights them up! That brings them joy!
Having a list to work from helps a lot with this. I’d much rather give something I know someone wants, even if that takes away the element of surprise. I used to think this was cheating, and feels less thoughtful, and less creative. But I listened to a great Hidden Brain podcast episode, I think it was The Secret to Gift Giving, that basically says, look, when you try to get creative with gifts and aren’t very good at it, it becomes about you as the gift giver — you’re trying to get the Wow! factor — rather than about the person you’re giving the gift to. In those cases, working from a wishlist and giving something the person actually wants is the thoughtful thing to do. They want something, you give it to them, they feel joy. I felt joy when I opened the backpack I really wanted, our daughter felt joy when she opened the perfume she wanted.
But what’s most fun is to give an experience. That’s become my favorite type of gift to give and receive. We took our kids to an NHL hockey game this year, and they loved that. We have fun memories now from that time together. My parents sent a charcuterie board for my birthday that my husband and I enjoyed one night with wine on the back deck. I remember how great it felt to not have to make a meal. I took my husband to New York City jazz clubs for his 50th birthday, and we had a fantastic time while we were there, and now have fantastic memories as well.
Apparently, this is one of the secrets to happiness, according to all of the happiness research I’ve been listening to the past couple of years: to share time together, and to connect socially. For maximal happiness, the best gift to give is the gift of experiences.
P.S. Happy 40th, Matt!